WHY BBBEE SHOULD STAY

When I look at South Africa today, I see a country brimming with potential but grappling with the heavy burden of inequality. While many argue that Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) and its updated framework, Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (BBBEE), have not done enough, I believe scrapping BBBEE would be a grave mistake. Let me explain why this policy is essential, how it has made an impact, and why we need to cast our votes for leaders who recognise that economic justice is not a luxury but a necessity.

A Snapshot of Inequality

South Africa remains one of the most unequal societies in the world. According to Statistics South Africa, the Gini coefficient, a measure of income inequality, sits at a staggering 0.63. This figure is a sobering reminder of the systemic injustices entrenched during apartheid—an era where opportunities were not just withheld but actively denied to the majority of the population.

In this context, BBBEE was not born as a handout or a quick-fix solution. It is a framework designed to level the playing field by addressing racial disparities in ownership, management, and economic participation. However, the policy has been met with scepticism, both locally and internationally, often criticised as ineffective or as fostering corruption. These arguments, while not entirely baseless, miss the bigger picture.

What is BBBEE Really About?

At its core, BBBEE is about creating opportunities for those who were historically excluded from the economy. It measures entities under the Codes of Good Practice, ensuring they contribute to transformation. These measurable entities include:

  • Organs of State and Public Entities
  • Measured Entities engaging economically with Organs of State and Public Entities
  • Any entity undertaking economic activity directly or indirectly with other measurable entities

What this means is that BBBEE isn’t just about big corporations ticking boxes. It touches every part of the economy, from state-owned enterprises to private businesses interacting with public institutions.

The Achievements So Far

While it’s easy to point out its flaws, BBBEE has led to some undeniable progress:

  1. Increased Black Ownership: According to the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition (DTIC), black ownership on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) increased from 3% in 1995 to 23% in 2022. While not perfect, this is significant progress.
  2. Skills Development: Companies are now investing in training and upskilling their employees. In 2020 alone, R19 billion was spent on skills development initiatives under BBBEE frameworks.
  3. Enterprise and Supplier Development: Through BBBEE, small black-owned businesses have received funding, mentorship, and opportunities to enter markets they previously couldn’t access. These initiatives contribute to job creation and economic diversification.

The Critics vs. Reality

Critics of BBBEE often claim it’s a failed experiment, citing corruption and fronting as major concerns. While these issues are real, they are not reasons to abandon the policy. Instead, they highlight the need for better enforcement and oversight.

Imagine this: if you had a leaking roof, would you tear down the entire house, or would you fix the roof? The same principle applies to BBBEE. Scrapping it would throw away the gains we’ve made and signal that we’re giving up on economic transformation altogether.

A Personal Perspective

I’ve seen the impact of BBBEE firsthand. In my work with small businesses, I’ve come across entrepreneurs who, thanks to supplier development programmes, were able to secure contracts that turned their small operations into thriving businesses. One entrepreneur I worked with started with a team of two employees. Today, they employ over 50 people. This isn’t just a win for them; it’s a win for their community.

On the other hand, I’ve also seen where the system falls short. Corruption and lack of transparency have, at times, diverted resources from those who need them most. These are challenges we must confront head-on, but abandoning BBBEE is not the solution.

The Road Ahead

To ensure BBBEE reaches its full potential, we need:

  1. Stronger Oversight: Establish independent bodies to monitor compliance and penalise fronting and corruption.
  2. Greater Inclusivity: Extend BBBEE benefits to rural areas and small towns, which often get left behind.
  3. Education and Awareness: Many businesses, especially small and medium-sized enterprises, struggle to understand BBBEE requirements. Simplifying the framework and offering guidance can make a big difference.
  4. Youth Empowerment: Focus on creating opportunities for young people. With youth unemployment at 60%, integrating young black South Africans into the economy is non-negotiable.

Why Voting Matters

As we approach another election cycle, I urge everyone to think about the kind of South Africa we want to build. This is not just about policies like BBBEE; it’s about recognising that economic justice is tied to social stability and national progress. By voting for leaders who prioritise reducing inequality, we can ensure that South Africa doesn’t just survive but thrives.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.